| Year | Winner | Runner-Up | Year | Winner | Runner-Up | Year | Winner | Runner-Up | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1965-66 | A Simmonds | 1990-91 | T Smith | G Sparke | 2006-07 | A Osborne | R Davis | |||
| 1966-67 | S Zebedee | 1992-93 | S Baker | 2007-08 | B Davis | F Arnold | ||||
| 1967-68 | T Brewster | 1993-94 | T Owen | 2008-09 | M Bruton | M Hall | ||||
| 1968-69 | G Browne | 1994-95 | A Keel | R Neal | 2009-10 | R Neal | B Asher | |||
| 1969-70 | G Thorne | 1995-96 | C Dalziel | J Edginton | 2010-11 | B Ling | G Dredge | |||
| 1970-71 | N Dredge | 1996-97 | J Baker | P Forrest | 2011-12 | B Asher | J Gibson | |||
| 1971-72 | T Brewster | 1997-98 | B King | D Veall | 2012-13 | F Arnold | J Chandler | |||
| 1972-73 | A Drake | R Plumb | 1998-99 | A Webster | D Hinton | 2013-14 | B Ling | K Garrett | ||
| 1973-74 | B Goodridge | 1999-00 | A Osborne | K Grist | 2014-15 | J Chandler | R Davis | |||
| 1974-75 | F Coffin | 2000-01 | A Webster | D Whitmarsh | 2015-16 | R Maggs | J Lambert | |||
| 1982-83 | A Drake | 2001-02 | P Trubridge | D Whitmarsh | 2016-17 | A Osborne | B Cudby | |||
| 1983-84 | G Sims | 2002-03 | K Grist | P Forrest | 2017-18 | D Parsons | B Cudby | |||
| 1987-88 | T Smith | 2003-04 | J Arnott | D Parsons | 2022-23 | S Robinson | J Lambert | |||
| 1988-89 | J Baker | 2004-05 | D Warn | J Arnott | 2023-24 | |||||
| 1989-90 | F Duffy | R Dredge | 2005-06 | D Parsons | M Hall |